Rare Condos Listed for Sale in New York’s Hidden Pomander Walk

An exceptional real estate opportunity has emerged in New York City, where two one-bedroom condos located on the picturesque Pomander Walk are up for sale, priced at a combined total of $1.39 million. This hidden gem, nestled between 94th and 95th Streets on the Upper West Side, offers a unique charm that resembles European-style cottages rather than bustling metropolitan life.

Pomander Walk, a quaint gated community built in 1921, is noteworthy for its distinctive Tudor-style architecture, originally designed by Irish immigrant Thomas Healy. The neighborhood, which has remained relatively unknown to many city residents, was inspired by the 1910 English play “Pomander Walk” and was designated a New York City landmark in 1982.

A Unique Living Experience

The available condos, situated on the second and third floors, present the rare possibility of being combined into a single duplex. Listing agent Kim Shankman described the area as “a hidden gem,” noting that it feels almost surreal to be in New York City while standing on the cobblestone pathway. The two units have been in the same family for over three decades, and their owners are now ready to pass them on to new residents who can appreciate the charm of this unique neighborhood.

According to Shankman, the original plan for Pomander Walk was to construct a single large building; however, the project was modified due to budget constraints, resulting in the creation of 27 individual three-story condominiums. The rarity of listings in this neighborhood is evident, as many owners tend to hold onto their properties for extended periods. Shankman shared that her clients have cherished their units, emphasizing their desire for new buyers to fall in love with the homes just as they did.

Details of the Condos

Each condo features a floor plan of approximately 500 square feet, consisting of one bedroom, a living room, an eat-in kitchen, and a bathroom. The units are currently listed for $699,000 each and can be sold separately. The family has maintained these properties for decades, and while they are ready to let go, it has proven to be an emotional decision for them.

Since 2009, only six units have been advertised for rent in Pomander Walk, reflecting the neighborhood’s tight-knit community. The last recorded sale was in 2023, when a two-bedroom unit was sold for $900,000. Shankman noted that the demand remains high, as the area continues to attract those seeking a unique and idyllic living environment in the heart of Manhattan.

Pomander Walk exemplifies a distinctive lifestyle that is rare in the ever-evolving landscape of New York City. With its beautiful architecture and tranquil atmosphere, it remains a sought-after enclave for potential buyers looking to invest in a piece of history.