Apple Watch 11 vs Samsung Galaxy Watch 8: Step-Counting Showdown

As consumers consider upgrading their smartwatches, the recent comparison between the Apple Watch 11 and the Samsung Galaxy Watch 8 sheds light on which device excels at step-counting accuracy. Both models launched in March 2023 and are highly regarded for their health and fitness features. To determine which watch performed better, a test involving a manual step count of 10,000 steps was conducted.

For the assessment, a manual clicker was used to tally each step taken, ensuring a precise count for comparison. Both watches were worn on the left wrist, while the clicker was operated with the right hand. The internal accelerometer in each watch tracked arm movements, which should have provided consistent results regardless of whether the watches were worn on a dominant or non-dominant hand.

Step-Counting Accuracy

The results from the step-counting test were revealing. During the first walk, the manual count recorded 5,345 steps, while the Apple Watch 11 reported 5,204 steps and the Galaxy Watch 8 indicated 5,362 steps. For the second walk, the manual count was 5,020 steps, with the Apple Watch 11 showing 4,842 steps and the Galaxy Watch 8 noting 4,985 steps.

Overall, the total manual recording resulted in 10,365 steps, with the Apple Watch 11 reporting 10,046 steps and the Galaxy Watch 8 at 10,347 steps. The Galaxy Watch 8’s performance was notably accurate, missing only 18 steps from the manual count. The Apple Watch 11, while slightly less precise, was only about 300 steps off, a minor discrepancy over a five-mile walk.

Additional Features and Ecosystem Considerations

Beyond step counting, both smartwatches offer a range of health features. The Galaxy Watch 8 includes advanced sleep monitoring, FDA-authorized sleep apnea detection, and a body composition analysis tool. In contrast, the Apple Watch 11 introduces a hypertension alert feature, notifying users of elevated blood pressure levels. However, it lacks some of Samsung’s fitness metrics, such as the daily energy score.

When choosing between these two devices, personal ecosystem compatibility plays a significant role. The Apple Watch 11 is designed for users within the iOS environment, while the Galaxy Watch 8 operates optimally with Android.

Ultimately, both smartwatches provide accurate step tracking, making them reliable companions for fitness enthusiasts. Whether opting for the Apple Watch 11 or the Samsung Galaxy Watch 8, users can expect a comprehensive suite of health and fitness tracking capabilities that enhance their daily activities.